🫐Sponsored by Berries: Use coupon code TherapyShow50 for $50 off your first month - CLICK HERE.🫐

Need CE contact hours? Explore my NBCC-Approved Podcourses & CE Courses

*This episode DOES NOT qualify for continuing education contact hours.

“I Don’t Know What to Talk About Today”: What to Do When Therapy Feels Stuck

If you’ve been a therapist for any length of time, you’ve probably had this happen.

A client sits down, you ask what they’d like to focus on, and they say:

“I don’t know what to talk about today.”

Or maybe:

“Nothing really happened this week.”

Or:

“I’m actually doing okay.”

And suddenly you’re wondering what you’re supposed to do with the next 50 minutes.

These sessions can create more anxiety for therapists than we sometimes admit. We can feel pressure to make the session productive, fill the silence, ask the right question, or find the hidden issue.

But a client not having an obvious agenda does not automatically mean the session is unproductive.

Sometimes, “I don’t know” is useful clinical information.

“I Don’t Know” Is Information

There are many reasons a client may come into session without a clear topic.

Maybe they had a relatively uneventful week.

Maybe things are actually going better.

Maybe they are emotionally depleted.

Maybe they have difficulty identifying what they are feeling.

Maybe they are avoiding something uncomfortable.

Maybe they are waiting for you to lead because that is what they think therapy is supposed to look like.

Or maybe they have reached a point where they no longer need the same frequency of therapy.

Those possibilities call for very different responses.

So rather than assuming the session is going nowhere, it can be helpful to ask:

What does “I don’t know” mean for this client today?

Notice Your Own Discomfort

Sometimes the pressure in these sessions is not only coming from the client.

It may also be coming from us.

When silence feels uncomfortable, therapists can quickly move into question mode:

“How was work?”

“How is your relationship?”

“How are things with your family?”

“How is your anxiety?”

“How are you sleeping?”

“Anything happen this weekend?”

Before long, the session starts to feel more like an interview than therapy.

That does not necessarily mean those are bad questions. But it can be useful to notice why we are asking them.

Are we following the client’s needs?

Or are we trying to relieve our own discomfort with silence?

Sometimes it helps to slow down.

You might say:

“We don’t have to rush to come up with something.”

Or:

“Take a minute and notice what’s coming up.”

Or even:

“What is it like for you to be here today without something specific you want to talk about?”

That question alone can open up meaningful material.

Go Back to the Treatment Goals

One of the simplest things you can do when a session feels directionless is revisit the reason the client came to therapy in the first place.

Treatment goals can easily fade into the background once therapy gets moving.

A quieter session can be a good opportunity to ask:

• “When you first came to therapy, what were you hoping would be different?”
• “How do you think you’re doing with that now?”
• “What has changed?”
• “What still feels unfinished?”
• “Is there anything you thought we would address that we haven’t really gotten to?”
• “If therapy were working exactly the way you hoped, what would be different in your life right now?”

Sometimes these questions reveal that the client is not stuck at all.

They may simply be doing better.

And that matters.

Move Beyond “What Happened This Week?”

Therapy can easily become organized around weekly events.

We ask:

“What happened this week?”

And the client reports what occurred.

There is nothing wrong with that.

But over time, it can unintentionally teach clients that therapy is primarily about bringing in a problem or crisis to discuss.

So when nothing dramatic happens, they may not know what therapy is supposed to be for.

Try broadening the conversation.

Instead of only asking about events, ask about internal experience.

You might ask:

• “What have you been thinking about lately?”
• “What has been taking up emotional space, even if nothing major happened?”
• “What have you noticed yourself avoiding?”
• “Where have you felt most like yourself lately?”
• “Where have you felt least like yourself?”
• “What are you tolerating right now that you wish were different?”
• “What have you wanted to say to someone but haven’t?”

These questions help move therapy beyond a weekly news report.

Use the Here-and-Now

If the client genuinely does not have much they want to talk about outside the room, the session itself can become the focus.

You might ask:

• “What are you noticing right now?”
• “What is it like to come in today without anything prepared?”
• “Do you feel pressure to bring something important every week?”
• “Do you worry I’ll think you don’t need therapy if things are going well?”
• “Are you waiting for me to decide what we should talk about?”

That last question can be especially useful.

For some clients, difficulty identifying what they want in session may reflect a larger relational pattern.

Maybe they are accustomed to other people taking the lead.

Maybe they struggle to identify their own needs.

Maybe they feel safer when someone else sets the agenda.

Now the “stuck” session is actually giving you useful information about the client.

Don’t Automatically Assume Avoidance

Sometimes “I don’t know” does reflect avoidance.

But sometimes it does not.

Not every quiet session means there is something the client refuses to discuss.

Maybe they truly had a calm week.

Maybe they are tired.

Maybe their symptoms are improving.

A helpful way to explore this without imposing a conclusion is to say:

“Sometimes when people don’t know what to talk about, it’s because things are going pretty well. Other times, there’s something they’re not quite ready to approach. I’m curious which of those feels closer today.”

That invites curiosity rather than confrontation.

If something does seem difficult to approach, you might ask:

• “What feels difficult about going there?”
• “What are you worried might happen if we talk about it?”
• “Is there anything you feel like you need to protect yourself from in this conversation?”

The goal is not to force content.

The goal is to understand what the quietness may be communicating.

Use Structured Prompts When Needed

Some clients do better when they have a little more structure.

That does not mean the therapy is less meaningful.

A few thoughtful prompts can help clients get started.

Try questions like:

• What felt hardest this week?
• What felt easiest?
• What did you avoid?
• What did you need but not ask for?
• When did you feel most anxious?
• When did you feel most calm?
• Was there a moment you wish you had handled differently?
• Did anyone disappoint you?
• Did you disappoint yourself?
• What are you worried might happen next?
• What are you hoping happens next?
• What has your mind been returning to?
• What are you not saying?

That last question can be particularly powerful with the right client and the right therapeutic relationship.

When Therapy Has Become Crisis-Driven

Some clients become accustomed to using therapy primarily for crisis management.

When there is a crisis, there is plenty to discuss.

When things settle down, they may not know what comes next.

This can be a good opportunity to shift the focus from survival to growth.

You might say:

“We’ve spent a lot of time putting out fires. Now that things are calmer, maybe we can think about what you want to build.”

That changes the question from:

What are we trying to survive?

to:

What are we trying to create?

You can explore:

• what kind of relationships the client wants
• how they want to communicate
• how they want to respond to stress
• what kind of parent, partner, friend, or professional they want to be
• what gives their life meaning
• what they want more of
• what they want less of

Therapy does not have to depend on crisis.

Maybe Therapy Frequency Needs to Change

If a client repeatedly arrives with very little to discuss and has made meaningful progress toward their goals, it may be worth talking about whether the current frequency of therapy is still necessary.

Maybe weekly therapy becomes biweekly.

Maybe biweekly becomes monthly.

Maybe the work shifts into maintenance.

Or maybe it is time to begin talking about termination.

That does not mean:

“You’re on your own.”

It can mean:

“You’ve made progress.”

“You have more tools.”

“You do not need the same level of support right now.”

“And you can return if you need help again.”

Sometimes therapists are so focused on keeping treatment useful that we overlook the possibility that reduced need for therapy is actually a positive outcome.

Sometimes a Quiet Session Means Therapy Is Working

A session without a crisis is not a failed session.

A client saying:

“Honestly, I’m doing pretty well”

can be good news.

You do not have to search for pathology just because there is still time on the clock.

Instead, you can:

• reflect on progress
• reinforce what is working
• identify relapse warning signs
• talk about future stressors
• review coping strategies
• discuss changes in frequency
• begin planning for termination

Sometimes a quieter session is an opportunity to recognize how far the client has come.

Don’t Confuse Filling the Hour With Doing Good Therapy

A full session is not necessarily a productive session.

A client can talk nonstop for 50 minutes and never get near anything meaningful.

Another client can sit quietly for a few minutes, recognize something important, and leave with a new understanding of themselves.

The therapist’s job is not to manufacture content.

The therapist’s job is to pay attention to what the client needs.

Sometimes that means structure.

Sometimes it means silence.

Sometimes it means reflection.

Sometimes it means revisiting goals.

And sometimes it means asking whether treatment itself needs to change.

A Simple Framework: Pause, Review, Explore, Decide

The next time a client says, “I don’t know what to talk about today,” try remembering four words:

Pause. Review. Explore. Decide.

Pause

Do not immediately rescue the session.

Give the client some space and notice your own urge to fill the silence.

Review

Return to the treatment goals.

What brought the client in?

What has improved?

What still needs attention?

Explore

Look at the internal experience.

What are they feeling?

What are they avoiding?

What is happening in the room?

What patterns might be showing up?

Decide

Ask what this moment tells you about where treatment should go next.

Does the client need a new focus?

More structure?

Less frequent sessions?

A conversation about termination?

That simple framework can help take the pressure off when a session initially feels directionless.

The Bottom Line

The next time your client says:

“I don’t know what to talk about today,”

you do not have to panic.

You do not have to turn into an interviewer.

And you do not have to manufacture a problem just to fill the hour.

Instead, get curious.

What does this moment tell you about where the client is?

Are they avoiding something?

Are they struggling to identify what they want?

Are they waiting for you to lead?

Have they made more progress than either of you has stopped to recognize?

Or is therapy simply ready to change?

Sometimes a session that begins with “I don’t know what to talk about” can end up becoming one of the most useful conversations you have.

Listen to the Episode

Listen to the full episode of The Therapy Show: “I Don’t Know What to Talk About Today”: What to Do When Therapy Feels Stuck for more practical ideas you can use in your next session.

I also recently released a new CE Podcourse, When Domestic Abuse Shows Up in Therapy: Recognition, Safety, and Referral, designed to help mental health professionals recognize warning signs, consider safety issues, and respond appropriately when domestic abuse shows up in clinical work.

You can explore that training and my other Therapy Show CE Podcourses here.

Free Resources for Therapists From Berries

This episode is also sponsored by Berries, an AI-powered clinical documentation tool for mental health professionals.

One of the things I appreciate most about the Berries team is how much they value the work therapists do. They have created free resources and free continuing education courses as a way of giving back to the mental health field.

You can explore those resources at: https://heyberries.com/blog?via=6788

If you want to try Berries for your own clinical documentation, you can try it for free and use code THERAPYSHOW50 for $50 off your first month.

This article is for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended to replace clinical judgment, supervision, consultation, or individualized treatment planning.